17700. [2] (Damon Knight) Beyond the Barrier

I’m revis­it­ing this lit­tle-known nov­el, which I read as a kid. I did­n’t remem­ber much detail, only a few of the odd­er inci­dents in the sto­ry, and its creepy atmos­phere. Damon Knight first made a rep­u­ta­tion as an acer­bic crit­ic, and was extreme­ly crit­i­cal of A. E. van Vogt’s work. So it’s iron­ic that this nov­el struck me as dis­tinct­ly “van Vogt­ian”. It cer­tain­ly has that author’s ten­den­cy to jerk you from one plot devel­op­ment to anoth­er, and to con­stant­ly shift its frame of ref­er­ence. There’s also a bit of a Philip K. Dick feel to it. The sto­ry starts with a pro­tag­o­nist with mem­o­ry loss, a dubi­ous iden­ti­ty, enig­mat­ic events, mur­der, aliens mas­querad­ing as humans, and soon drifts into time-trav­el, wan­der­ing about an emp­ty space ship after the human race is extinct, and even has the main char­ac­ter fall through the earth like a yo-yo. The stuff is just piled on. And yet, it’s readable.

In fact, it was just this kind of stuff, with no lit­er­ary pre­ten­sions, that made read­ing SF such a plea­sure. The ideas just tum­bled out, willy-nil­ly. They were fun to think about. There was a play­ful­ness, an irrev­er­ence, and an “out­sider” feel­ing that you sensed in the writ­ers that can’t be found in today’s SF. Damon Knight was one of those writ­ers you pic­tured meet­ing in a seedy bar at one in the morn­ing, nurs­ing a glass of Jim Beam. Noth­ing like the tedious­ly respectable types who dom­i­nate the field today. (Come to think of it, I once met van Vogt — in a seedy bar at one in the morn­ing, and we talked for hours)

Leave a Comment