Tuesday, August 1, 2006 — Defending the Northwest Passage

The Northwest Passage seen from space.

The North­west Pas­sage seen from space.

It’s like a piz­za oven out there. Extreme heat and humid­i­ty, which is thank­ful­ly expect­ed to break tomor­row. Hard to find any­one who doubts glob­al warming.

Wash­ing­ton, of course, still pre­tends it isn’t hap­pen­ing. But it has aggres­sive­ly renewed its asser­tions that the North­west Pas­sage is not Cana­di­an ter­ri­to­r­i­al waters. Glob­al warm­ing means the ice-bound pas­sage is open­ing up, and will soon become eco­nom­i­cal­ly sig­nif­i­cant. Canada’s claim to sov­er­eign­ty over the chan­nel through its arc­tic arch­i­pel­ago will even­tu­al­ly become the main source of con­flict between the Unit­ed States and Cana­da. [see my arti­cle from last year on the relat­ed Hans Island controversy].

So I’m pleased that the CBC Nation­al News is being broad­cast, this week, from an ice-break­er going through the Pas­sage. It will draw some pub­lic atten­tion to this issue.

At the moment, we have very lit­tle to effec­tive­ly assert Cana­di­an sov­er­eign­ty in the arc­tic arch­i­pel­ago, which is all in the sparse­ly inhab­it­ed ter­ri­to­ry of Nunavut. Mil­i­tar­i­ly, we have noth­ing but CFS Alert, at the north­ern tip of Ellesmere Island, and a mili­tia of Inu­it reservists who are armed with WWI vin­tage rifles! Alert had only five per­ma­nent inhab­i­tants in the 2001 cen­sus (though it qual­i­fied as the world’s north­ern­most set­tle­ment). Alert is actu­al­ly clos­er to Moscow than it is to Ottawa, so it is not sur­pris­ing that it had over two hun­dred per­son­nel sta­tioned there at the height of the Cold War. Nowa­days, how­ev­er, only about 75 peo­ple man the mil­i­tary sig­nals intel­li­gence radio receiv­ing facil­i­ty, and a few more man the Envi­ron­ment Cana­da weath­er sta­tion and the Glob­al Atmos­phere Watch mon­i­tor­ing facil­i­ty. The envi­ron­ment is not many people’s idea of a hol­i­day des­ti­na­tion. From mid-Octo­ber through the end of Feb­ru­ary the sun does not rise above the hori­zon and there is 24-hour dark­ness from the end of Octo­ber until mid-Feb­ru­ary. The cap­i­tal town of Nunavut, Iqualuit, is 2,100 km to the south.

Ellesmere is a huge island with a maze of colos­sal, rugged moun­tains and glac­i­ers. In 1991, when a CC130 Her­cules trans­port crashed only 18 km (10 miles) away from the base, it took 32 hours for a res­cue team to reach the sur­vivors over­land. Yes, the ter­rain is that bad. There is anoth­er research sta­tion, not always manned, at Eure­ka, and a small Inu­it set­tle­ment, Grise Fjord, on an island near the south­ern tip of Ellesmere. On Devon Island, there is the Haug­ton-MARS research sta­tion which stud­ies the 20km-wide Haughton mete­or impact crater and takes advan­tage of the harsh envi­ron­ment for var­i­ous exper­i­ments by SETI and the Mars Soci­ety, and such odd­i­ties as the Arthur Clarke Mars Green­house. There are only ten peo­ple who are there for any length of time, and a hand­ful of Inu­it high school stu­dents who are hired to keep them from killing them­selves. How­ev­er, this is on the wrong side of the island to mon­i­tor the Pas­sage. There was once a plan to cre­ate a set­tle­ment on Ellef Rignes Island, near the North Mag­net­ic Pole, but the plan was aban­doned, and there is noth­ing there now but a robot­ic unit.

The only inhab­it­ed place along the Pas­sage is Res­olute [Qausuit­tuq (pop.215)]. It is well placed, at the nar­row­est point in the pas­sage, and rough­ly in the mid­dle. But there is absolute­ly noth­ing at either the west­ern or east­ern entrances to the passage.

We are entire­ly depen­dent on satel­lite obser­va­tion to mon­i­tor traf­fic through the pas­sage, and that is use­less for sub­marines. The U.S. has made a point of thumb­ing it’s nose at the Cana­di­an gov­ern­ment, by run­ning subs through with­out ask­ing per­mis­sion. The Rus­sians have also poked around secret­ly. As the arc­tic ice pack melts, marine tech­nol­o­gy advances, oil prices rise, and the pas­sage becomes more viable, there will be increas­ing pres­sure from Wash­ing­ton and oth­er world powers.

The present admin­is­tra­tion has promised to beef up the Inu­it mili­tia, and to posi­tion a train­ing cen­tre for it in Res­olute, but this is hard­ly ade­quate. We need to build mon­i­tor­ing facil­i­ties at both ends of the pas­sage, and to estab­lish a much greater mil­i­tary and sci­en­tif­ic pres­ence in the entire 1.9 mil­lion square km of Nunavut.

We are present­ly bogged down in an expen­sive oper­a­tion in Afghanistan, which has become more and more under the thumb of the U.S. mil­i­tary, and has ceased to have any­thing to do either with hunt­ing down Al Kai­da, or estab­lish­ing viable civ­il soci­ety in that coun­ty. I am fair­ly con­vinced that George W. Bush has been com­mit­ted, from the very start, to sab­o­tag­ing any seri­ous effort to revenge 9/11 or catch Bin Laden. Since help­ing the Afghan peo­ple, and hunt­ing down Bin Laden were the rea­sons that Cana­di­ans sup­port­ed (over­whelm­ing­ly) our pres­ence there, I think it time we said “shit, or get off the pot” to Wash­ing­ton. Our mil­i­tary resources would be bet­ter employed defend­ing our North than run­ning around in a dis­as­trous, Amer­i­can-man­aged gueril­la war among trib­al drug lords.

Leave a Comment