(Krishna 1991) Masala; (Mehta 2002) Bollywood / Hollywood

Masala (1991)

Both these films, made eleven years apart, are sur­re­al­is­tic come­dies about Indo-Cana­di­an fam­i­lies in Toron­to. I first saw Masala with a room­ful of friends, some of South Asian back­ground, some not, but all Cana­di­ans raised in Toron­to. I think we all enjoyed it more for its “Toron­to-ness” than for any­thing as dourly seri­ous as “iden­ti­ty pol­i­tics”. It had the feel of our city, and the same goofi­ness that you would see in Strange Brew. See­ing the ven­er­a­ble Saeed Jaf­frey as the God Krish­na in a Leaf’s goalie uni­form had us rolling on the floor with laugh­ter. And the same actor por­trays the long-suf­fer­ing postal clerk, to whom Lord Krish­na deliv­ers the rarest Cana­di­an stamp, but who is unwill­ing to sell it either to sat­is­fy his wife’s crav­ing for appli­ances, or the gov­ern­men­t’s pres­sure, and is the Cana­di­an Every­man in a nutshell. 

Bol­ly­wood / Hol­ly­wood is a slick­er film, with bet­ter pro­duc­tion val­ues, but it isn’t as fun­ny. The char­ac­ters are less lik­able and less inno­cent. It’s hard­er to sym­pa­thize with the iden­ti­ty angst of peo­ple who live in huge sub­ur­ban man­sions. What makes the film fun­ny is that it reg­u­lar­ly breaks out into full-scale Bol­ly­wood-style musi­cal num­bers. That’s the big joke in the film: how the weird fan­ta­sy world of the musi­cals ground out by Mum­bai’s huge film indus­try fits in with the atti­tudes of this finan­cial­ly suc­cess­ful immi­grant com­mu­ni­ty in Cana­da. The fun­ni­est part is when a horde of non-South Asian busi­ness exec­u­tives break out into one of these absurd song-and-dance num­bers.

Hol­ly­wood / Bol­ly­wood (2002)

Leave a Comment