Image of the month:
FILMS JULY-SEPTEMBER 2007
(McKellar 1998) Last Night
(Arbuckle 1917) The Butcher Boy [w. Roscoe Arbuckle & Buster Keaton]
(Arbuckle 1917) The Rough House [w. Roscoe Arbuckle & Buster Keaton]
(Arbuckle 1917) His Wedding Night [w. Roscoe Arbuckle & Buster Keaton]
(Arbuckle 1917) Oh, Doctor! [w. w. Roscoe Arbuckle & Buster Keaton]
(Godwin 1999) Wonders of the African World: The Road to Timbuktu
(Appio 1999) Wonders of the African World: Lost Citis of the South
(Hathaway 1953) Niagara Read more »
First-time listening for September, 2007
17575. The Music of Islam: Volume 1 — Al Qahirah [Music of Cairo]
17576. (Maurice Ravel) Sérénade grotesque
17577. (Maurice Ravel) Valses nobles et sentimentales
17578. (Thelonius Monk) Thelonius Monk with John Coltrane — The Complete April-July 1957
. . . . . Recordings
17579. (Cowboy Junkies) The Caution Horses
17580. (Wilhelm Stenhammar) Snöfrid, Op.5
17581. (Wilhelm Stenhammar) Mellanspel ur kantaten “Sången”, Op.44
Read more »
READING – SEPTEMBER 2007
15184. [2] (Pierre Berton) The Arctic Grail – The Quest for the North West Passage and the
. . . . . North Pole, 1818–1909
15185. (J. R. Maddicott) Simon de Montfort
15186. (China Miéville) Perdido Street Station
15187. (S. A. Nigosian) The Zoroastrian Faith – Tradition and Modern Research
15188. (Ann Gibbons) Fossil Teeth From Ethiopia Support Early, African Origin for Apes [article]
15189. [2] (Epicurus) Letter to Herodotus [tr. C. Bailey]
15190. [2] (Epicurus) Letter to Pythocles [tr. C. Bailey]
15191. [2] (Epicurus) Letter to Menoeceus [tr. C. Bailey]
15192. [2] (Epicurus) Principle Doctrines [tr. C. Bailey]
15193. (Jason A. Ur, Philip Karsgaard & Joan Oates) Early Urban Development in the Near East [article]
Read more »
Marie-Élaine Thibert
Marie-Élaine Thibert is a Montreal singer with a strong voice, which is reminiscent of Barbara Streisand’s. She first came to public attention when she belted out Jacques Brel’s technically difficult song “La quête”, on Quebec’s major talent show, Star Académie. The stadium-show-tunes kind of stuff is not really my kind of music, but I can appreciate the talent here. Quebec seems to grow highly professional mainstream singers as easily as British Columbia grows marijuana. There seems to be an endless supply. But only a few of them, such as Céline Dion, break out into the rest of the world. On the strength of this album, which has confident showmanship, I would guess that she will make it out, probably first in Europe. I haven’t heard all her second album, Comme ça, but it has a hit in a cover of Monique Leyrac’s old standard “Pour cet amour”, a duet with Chris deBurgh (a translation of “Lonely Sky”), and a very fine, subtle song I’ve heard online, “Les herbes hautes”.
FOURTH MEDITATION ON DEMOCRACY (written Saturday, September 22, 2007)
Recently, two Canadian high school students did a remarkable thing. It was remarkable enough to generate a large amount of comment in the blogosphere. According to the original news item in the Halifax Chronicle Herald [1], a grade 9 student “arrived for the first day of school last Wednesday and was set upon by a group of six to 10 older students who mocked him, called him a homosexual for wearing pink and threatened to beat him up.” Anyone who has attended high school knows the usual outcome of such situations. But in this case, it was different. Two senior students, Travis Price and David Shepherd, were disgusted by this crude bullying. “It’s my last year. I’ve stood around too long and I wanted to do something,” David explained. The two students bought 75 pink tank-tops and, rallying students through the internet, persuaded half the student body to wear them, or to supply their own. When the bullies next came to school, they were confronted by an ocean of pink solidarity. “The bullies got angry,” said Travis. “One guy was throwing chairs (in the cafeteria). We’re glad we got the response we wanted.”
The protest rapidly spread to thirty other Nova Scotia schools, then across the rest of Canada. High schools are no longer isolated, self-contained, stratified, and despotic mini-societies. Social networking media like Facebook and MySpace are enabling rapid, fluid and democratic communication, not only between students in the same school, but linking them to every other school in the world. Read more »
(Morris 2004) The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. MacNamara
I strongly recommend this film. It’s probably the best of the political documentaries circulating today. Since newspapers, radio and television have stopped being of any use to anyone who wants to learn things about politics, documentary films have emerged as the most effective medium for discussing public affairs.
For those who are too young to recognize the name, Robert Strange McNamara was one of the pioneers of strategic systems analysis during WWII, and served as Secretary of Defense for Kennedy and Johnson from 1961 to 1968. He then became President of the World Bank until his retirement in 1981. What is now called “policy analysis” is an amplification of the “systems analysis” that he introduced to the Pentagon. Understanding McNamara’s background, psychology and motives is essential for any attempt to evaluate American foreign policy during the 1960s. Read more »
15187. (S. A. Nigosian) The Zoroastrian Faith – Tradition and Modern Research
I’ve been reading some things, such as this book, about Persian religion before Islam. What follows is based as much on Paul Kriwaczek’s In Search of Zarathustra[item 15183] as on this book, as well as on earlier reading [Mary Boyce Zoroastrians: Their Religious Beliefs and Practices; M. J. Vermaseren Mithras, the Secret God, the Zoroastrian scriptures, and many books on ancient Persia and on the dualist Christian heresies of the middle ages. The more I look at it, the more I’m convinced that an understanding of ancient Persian history is essential to putting together an intelligible picture of the ancient world. The more I read about the Zoroastrian tradition, the more I come to see it as smack dab in the center of a continuum of culture between India and Mediterranean. I was looking for evidence of consular institutions, either in religious or secular bodies, but the evidence is too fragmentary and ambiguous to permit any secure statements. This drives me crazy, because just one or two clear-cut examples would buttress my instinctive belief that urban and tribal consular institutions operated in pretty much the same way across the continuum. In other words, thousands of nameless and forgotten “republics”, confederacies, oligarchies and monarchies struggling with the same issues as the Indian and Greek ones, scattered everywhere. But how to prove it, when only two regions provide us with any kind of documentation? You can’t infer it from the archaeology. Read more »
The Death of Pavarotti
Well, there’s not much I can say about Pavarotti that others aren’t better qualified to say. He is one of those figures that steps out of a genre. People who hardly ever listen to jazz know Louis Armstrong, people who hardly ever listen to opera know Pavarotti, who successfully stepped into the shoes of Caruso as the ambassador of opera to the broad public. He fulfilled the role brilliantly, using his comical, un-threatening appearance to advantage. It was as if your favourite jolly uncle had super-powers, which he only used after dinner. On hearing of his death, I played his wonderful duet with James Brown, and his rather peculiar one with Lou Reed. Then I went through Pavarotti’s Greatest Hits, with his famed arias from Rigolettoand L’élisir d’Amore, among others. Then I played his album of Neapolitan folk songs, O Sole Mio, and his album of Christmas carols, O Holy Night. Over the course of the next two days, I played a few entire operas in which he starred: Bellini’s Beatrice di Tenda, and I Puritani, where he sang with Joan Sutherland, one of the few women with the stature and lung power to stand up to him in the ring; as well as an early performance of Puccini’s La Bohème, with Freni, directed by von Karajan.
Robert Volkmann
Ten years ago, CBCradio broadcast Robert Volkmann’s Symphony #1 in D. I was charmed by it. The announcer said that it sounded like “a forgotten work by Brahms”. True enough, and Volkmann’s obscurity could easily be explained by saying he was one of Brahms’ many imitators. But that symphony was composed in 1862, and Brahms’ first symphony didn’t appear until fourteen years later. I’ve never been able to find a copy of that symphony, and didn’t hear the whole thing on the CBCbroadcast, so it isn’t listed in my listening files. But I have obtained two works by him, the Konzertstückfor Piano &Orchestra, and the Cello Concerto. Both are entertaining and well-crafted, but not overwhelming. The cello concerto is worth several listens. Both works reveal his real influence: Schumann. Volkmann lived from 1815 to 1883. He was born in Saxony, spent a short stint in Prague, then the rest of his life in Budapest. He was respected and often played in his lifetime, but fell out of the repertory after his death. It’s more fair to say that he was a serious composer whose work followed on Schumann and anticipated Brahms, whom he influenced significantly. This is not dismissible as mere imitation. But time has a way of casting off such in-betweens.


